Content Warning: Family estrangement, childhood abandonment, emotional trauma
Privacy Note: Names, locations, and identifying details have been changed to protect privacy. The emotional truth remains unchanged.
It has been an entire year since my mother found her way back into my life, or more accurately, since she found her way into my inbox. A full year of messages, life updates, and notifications quietly lighting up my screen. And during this entire year, I have done the exact same thing every single time: I have read them, and I have not replied. I have not answered her messages, I have not returned her phone calls, and I have not told her to stop sending them either. I have simply watched from a distance, reading and listening, trying to make sense of what was happening. Throughout all those months of quiet observation, there is one particular thing that I have not been able to shake. It is the overwhelming sense of familiarity in the way she speaks to me.
Have you ever had someone walk back into your life after decades away and act as though they only stepped out of the room for a few minutes? That is the closest way I can explain what it feels like. My mother sends messages asking how I am doing. It is such a simple, everyday question, the kind of normal inquiry parents ask their children all the time. Yet every single time I see those words on my screen, I find myself freezing. Twenty-five years went by before she asked that question. Twenty-five years of complete absence. And yet, the tone of her message often feels like she last saw me last week, as if I had merely been away on a short trip and forgot to check in.
There are moments when she sends texts telling me how much she misses me, and whenever I read that, a question instantly rises in my mind: which version of me does she actually miss? Does she miss the thirteen-year-old child she walked away from, or does she miss the grown woman she has never spent a single day getting to know? Because those are two entirely different people. She writes that she loves me over and over again, as if that love has always been an unbroken thread tying us together across all these decades. She speaks as though our connection remained completely intact while time moved forward, as if twenty-five years was nothing more than a temporary pause in a conversation rather than an entire lifetime lived apart.
The hardest part for me is not the words themselves, but the assumptions living underneath them. I do not think she is being malicious, and I do not believe she is trying to cause harm. In a strange way, that makes it even harder to understand. When someone intentionally hurts you, your mind knows how to process the pain and put up a defense. But what are you supposed to do when someone seems completely oblivious to the vast expanse of time between you? How do you respond to someone who speaks as if yesterday was right there, while erasing a quarter of a century of silence? Reading her messages sometimes makes me feel like we are living in two completely different versions of the exact same story. In her version, she has simply returned. In mine, she was gone.
There is a moment from this past year that I have not been able to stop thinking about. Sometime after she reconnected with her siblings, who had also experienced her absence for many years, she ended up on a phone call that was put on loudspeaker. During that call, she heard my father speaking. For perhaps the very first time, she heard the raw hurt and the fallout she had left in her wake. It was not my hurt she was hearing, but his. The pain, the heavy struggle, and the brutal reality of what he had to carry alone after she vanished from our lives. I have thought about that moment so many times. I wonder what it felt like for her to finally hear that truth from the other side. Did it change anything for her? Did it shock her? Did it make the consequences of her leaving feel real?
I do not know the answers to those questions, and honestly, I am not even sure I want to ask. What stays with me is not just that phone call, but what happened afterward. The messages kept coming in the exact same casual tone. The breezy familiarity never wavered. She continued to write to me as if we shared a continuous history that never missed a beat. That is where so much of my discomfort comes from. We do have a shared history, of course we do, but we also have a massive, shared absence. I do not understand how you can build a relationship on the first without ever acknowledging the reality of the second.
If you have ever had someone walk back into your life after years of vanishing, maybe you know this feeling. The truth is, I do not hate my mother. I do not spend my days carrying an overwhelming rage toward her. If anything, what I sit with most often is a quiet, heavy confusion. How are two people supposed to pick up where they left off when where they left off was twenty-five years ago? How do you reconnect with someone who feels deeply familiar and entirely foreign at the exact same moment? Maybe that is the real reason I named this space Familiar Stranger. It is not because she is purely a stranger, and it is not because she is simply familiar. It is because, after all these years, she is somehow both.
If someone disappeared from your life for decades and came back speaking as though no time had passed at all, how would you feel? Would that familiarity bring you comfort, or would it make the lost years feel even heavier?
Love, Phoenix
Leave a Reply